The learned Rajasthan Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, Jaipur, in a recent ruling has upheld the penalty imposed by the Regulatory Authority on the promoter for advertising and selling units in an unregistered project. The case is important because it clarifies that even where ownership of the land is disputed or shared, a person advertising or marketing a project falls within the definition of a “promoter” under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA Act).
Case Background
The controversy began when Rajasthan RERA took suo motu cognizance of advertisements published in the Pali edition for a commercial project Y. The Authority found that bookings and sales of shops and plots were being carried out without registration, in violation of Section 3 of the RERA Act.
A show-cause notice was issued to the appellant X asking why penalty under Section 59 (up to 10% of project cost) should not be imposed.
The appellant argued:
- It had purchased only 4 shops from third parties and was not the actual promoter.
- The project area was below 500 sq. meters and did not exceed 8 units, hence exempt under Section 3(2).
- Another project Z was already registered, and the current land should not attract separate registration.
RERA rejected these arguments and imposed a penalty of Rs 5,00,000, directing registration of the project within 30 days.
Issues Raised
- Whether appellant company X could be treated as a “promoter” under Section 2(zk) of the RERA Act.
- Whether the project Y was exempt from registration on the ground that it involved less than 500 sq. meters or 8 units.
- Whether a previously registered project Z covered the impugned project.
Legal Findings
The Tribunal made several important observations:
- Definition of Promoter (Section 2(zk)): A person advertising or selling plots/shops, even if not the original landowner, is a “promoter.” Both landowners and marketers are deemed jointly liable.
- Violation of Section 3: The advertisements clearly offered 9 commercial shops for sale, crossing the statutory exemption limit of 8 units. Thus, the project required registration with RERA.
- Separate Projects: Project Y and Project Z were distinct schemes. Registration of one did not exempt the other.
- Responsibility of the Advertiser: Since appellant X’s name and contact number appeared in the advertisement, it could not avoid liability by blaming third parties.
The Tribunal also dismissed technical objections raised by the appellant regarding authorization and maintainability of the appeal.
Judgment
The Appellate Tribunal upheld RERA’s order dated 08/09/2023:
- The penalty of Rs 5,00,000 on the promoter was confirmed.
- The promoter must register the project within 30 days.
- The 30% pre-deposit already made under Section 43(5) will be transferred to Raj-RERA’s account.
Takeaways
This ruling reiterates that:
- Any person who markets, advertises, or sells a project can be treated as a promoter under RERA, regardless of whether they own the land.
- Registration is mandatory if a project involves more than 8 units or exceeds 500 sq. meters.
- Developers cannot escape liability by claiming the project belongs to someone else if they themselves advertise and facilitate sales.
For builders and developers, this judgment is a reminder that compliance with Section 3 of the RERA Act is non-negotiable. For homebuyers, it reinforces RERA’s role in ensuring transparency and accountability in the real estate sector.
A related appeal before the same Tribunal held that a project takeover does not wipe out the earlier builder’s liabilities.
This is a report of a decision of the Rajasthan Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, Jaipur, written for general information. Party names and identifying particulars have been omitted. It is not legal advice on any specific matter.